Underwriting Manager Jobs in Indiana

Underwriting Manager jobs in Indiana are open across Jeffersonville, Carmel, and Fort Wayne and other Indiana metros, with employers like AIG, Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, and Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company hiring at every experience level. Find a role that fits below and apply directly.

Find Underwriting Manager Jobs

Overview

Open roles5+
Top employerAIG
Top cityJeffersonville, IN
Cities hiring4
Work type80% On-site
Top industryInsurance

Showing 5 of 5+ Underwriting Manager jobs

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Underwriting Product Owner
We won't show you this job again
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Added 1w ago
Underwriting Product Owner
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Product Management
Business Analysis
Project & Program Management
Project Management
On-Site
Bachelor's
201-500

Have you applied for this role?

AIG
Underwriting Technician
We won't show you this job again
AIG
Added 3w ago
Underwriting Technician
AIG
Jeffersonville, Indiana
Finance
Accounting
Business Operations
Compliance & Legal
Project & Program Management
Audit
On-Site
Bachelor's

Have you applied for this role?

Indiana Farmers Insurance
Underwriting Technical Coordinator
We won't show you this job again
Indiana Farmers Insurance
Added 1mo ago
Underwriting Technical Coordinator
Indiana Farmers Insurance
Indianapolis, Indiana
Project & Program Management
Business Analysis
Customer Service & Support
Project Management
Hybrid
Bachelor's
201-500

Have you applied for this role?

Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, Inc.
Underwriting Technician, Warranty
We won't show you this job again
Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, Inc.
Added 1mo ago
Underwriting Technician, Warranty
Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, Inc.
Jeffersonville, Indiana
Finance
Accounting
Business Operations
Compliance & Legal
Project & Program Management
Audit
On-Site
Associate's

Have you applied for this role?

FCCI Insurance Group
Supervisor, Underwriting Operations
We won't show you this job again
FCCI Insurance Group
Added 4mo ago
Supervisor, Underwriting Operations
FCCI Insurance Group
Carmel, Indiana
Project & Program Management
Business Operations
Customer Service & Support
Customer Service
$62k - $96k/yr
On-Site
None

Have you applied for this role?

Looking for more underwriting manager jobs?

Explore related role searches to find more openings that fit.

See related jobs

See All 5 Underwriting Manager Jobs in Indiana

Find roles in Indiana that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.

Find Underwriting Manager Jobs

Underwriting Manager Jobs by City in Indiana

Where Indiana roles are concentrated, by current openings.

Jeffersonville
2 jobs
Carmel
1 jobs
Fort Wayne
1 jobs
Indianapolis
1 jobs

Underwriting Manager Job Market in Indiana

A snapshot from current Indiana openings, updated as new roles post.

Who's Hiring

  • AIG
    AIG1
  • Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency
    Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency1
  • Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
    Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company1
  • FCCI Insurance
    FCCI Insurance1
  • Indiana Farmers Insurance
    Indiana Farmers Insurance1

Top Industries Hiring

  • Insurance4

What Indiana Employers Look For

The qualifications that appear most often in underwriting manager jobs across Indiana.

  • 5 or more years of underwriting experience with demonstrated management or team lead responsibility
  • Deep knowledge of underwriting guidelines, risk assessment, and pricing within a specific line of business
  • Experience managing a team of underwriters and conducting performance reviews
  • Strong proficiency with underwriting platforms such as Guidewire, Duck Creek, or proprietary carrier systems
  • CPCU, AU, or CU designation preferred or required depending on the role and carrier
  • Bachelor's degree in business, finance, risk management, or a related field

Underwriting Manager Jobs in Indiana: Frequently Asked Questions

How many underwriting manager jobs are there in Indiana?

There are 5+ underwriting manager openings in Indiana on Migrate Mate as of June 2026, with the most roles in Jeffersonville, Carmel, and Fort Wayne. New positions post regularly as employers across Indiana hire.

How much do underwriting managers make in Indiana?

Underwriting managers in Indiana earn a median of about $77,440 a year, based on May 2025 Bureau of Labor Statistics wage data, ranging from around $48,160 for the lowest 10% to over $104,580 for the top 10%. Pay rises with experience, specialty, and employer.

Which Indiana cities have the most underwriting manager jobs?

Jeffersonville, Carmel, and Fort Wayne have the most underwriting manager openings in Indiana right now, with additional roles spread across smaller metros statewide.

Which companies hire underwriting managers in Indiana?

Employers hiring underwriting managers in Indiana include AIG, Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, and Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company, based on current listings on Migrate Mate as of June 2026.

Are there remote underwriting manager jobs in Indiana?

Yes. About 20% of underwriting manager openings tied to Indiana are remote or hybrid as of June 2026. The rest are on-site roles based in Indiana metros.

How do I apply for underwriting manager jobs in Indiana?

You can apply to underwriting manager jobs in Indiana directly on Migrate Mate. Search the listings above, find roles that match your experience and preferred Indiana location, then apply to each one that fits.

See All 5 Underwriting Manager Jobs in Indiana

Find roles in Indiana that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.

Find Underwriting Manager Jobs