Insurance Agency Owner Jobs in New York
Insurance Agency Owner jobs in New York are open across New York and Williamsville and other New York metros, with employers like Risk Specialists Companies Insurance Agency, Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, and Farmers Insurance hiring at every experience level. Find a role that fits below and apply directly.
Find Insurance Agency Owner JobsOverview
Showing 5 of 7+ Insurance Agency Owner jobs











INTRODUCTION
At AIG, we are reimagining the way we help customers to manage risk. Join us as a Senior Underwriter, North America Fronting to play your part in that transformation. It’s an opportunity to grow your skills and experience as a valued member of the team.
AIG underwriting teams help to find insurance solutions in areas including Financial Lines, Property, Casualty, Specialty Lines, Cyber, Multinational Clients, and High Net Worth individuals. We are reimagining how we help customers to manage risk, transforming our operating model, and reshaping our role responsibilities and career pathways. The goal is to unlock the full potential in each colleague – empowering our people to grow as insurance professionals and add more value to our customers and AIG.
This position is a Senior Underwriter for North America Fronting. Main focus will be the support and servicing of complex fronting accounts. The position will require an individual to have general knowledge of multiple lines of coverage and topics. They will support the Senior Team leader and assume account responsibilities under their direction.
ROLE AND RESPONSIBILITIES
How you will create an impact:
- Work closely with Captive Solutions Fronting Team and liaise with Product pillars to verify program structure and reinsurer details.
- Work closely with the support teams (Legal, Actuarial, Credit & Collateral Management) to ensure fronting deals are in full compliance.
- Once bound, collect all necessary program (premium and claims) details and reinsurance documentation.
- Perform sanctions and screening checks.
- Work with Associate Underwriter to ensure booking and coding on accounts are completed.
- Ensure cash collections and onward transfers to captives/reinsurers are prompt and in line with bookings.
- Resolve account-related questions from internal peers and/or Clients/ Brokers that are within their scope; or escalate to leadership.
- Make independent sales calls to market and cross-market products. Refers declined business to other AIG divisions, as appropriate.
- Participate in client (internal/external) conference calls.
- Prepare for and help respond to all captive audits.
BASIC QUALIFICATIONS
What you'll need to succeed:
- 3+ yrs relevant experience, preferably within the insurance industry.
- Must be articulate and personable as there will be communication with clients and brokers including attendance at meetings.
- Proactive, highly motivated, well-organized, self-sufficient, and able to demonstrate the ability to work productively under minimum supervision.
- Excellent time management skills with ability to work with deadlines and be responsive and flexible to client needs and changes in program requirements.
- Ability to manage by influence demonstrating strong communication, relationship management, organizational and analytical skills.
- Ability to work in dynamic, rapidly changing environment, adapting to changing requirements and collaborating with a wide range of colleagues to deliver expected results.
- Highly motivated and results-oriented, proven creative problem solver.
- Demonstrated ability to understand and work with analytical tools, reports and technology.
- Computer literacy required: Microsoft IT packages preferred – MS Outlook, Teams, Excel, Word, etc.
COMPENSATION
For positions based in Boston the base salary range for this position is $80,000-$100,000 and the position is eligible for a bonus in accordance with the terms of the applicable incentive plan. For positions based in New York the base salary range for this position is $80,000-$100,000 and the position is eligible for a bonus in accordance with the terms of the applicable incentive plan. Your actual compensation will be dependent on your skills, experience, and qualifications. If your compensation expectations are above the posted range, we still encourage you to apply - your unique background matters to us. In addition, we’re proud to offer a range of competitive benefits, a summary of which can be viewed here: US Benefits Overview.
At AIG, we value in-person collaboration as a vital part of our culture, which is why we ask our team members to be primarily in the office. This approach helps us work together effectively and create a supportive, connected environment for our team and clients alike.
BENEFITS
Enjoy benefits that take care of what matters:
At AIG, our people are our greatest asset. We know how important it is to protect and invest in what’s most important to you. That is why we created our Total Rewards Program, a comprehensive benefits package that extends beyond time spent at work to offer benefits focused on your health, wellbeing and financial security—as well as your professional development—to bring peace of mind to you and your family.
CULTURE OF INCLUSION
We’re committed to creating a culture that truly respects and celebrates each other’s talents, backgrounds, cultures, opinions and goals. We foster a culture of inclusion and belonging through learning, cultural awareness activities and Employee Resource Groups (ERGs). With global chapters, ERGs are a cornerstone for our culture of inclusion. The talent of our people is one of AIG’s greatest assets, and we are honored that our drive for positive change has been recognized by numerous recent awards and accreditations.
AIG provides equal opportunity to all qualified individuals regardless of race, color, religion, age, gender, gender expression, national origin, veteran status, disability or any other legally protected categories.
AIG is committed to working with and providing reasonable accommodations to job applicants and employees with disabilities. If you believe you need a reasonable accommodation, please send an email to candidatecare@aig.com.
FUNCTIONAL AREA
UW - Underwriting
Risk Specialists Companies Insurance Agency, Inc.
See All 7 Insurance Agency Owner Jobs in New York
Find roles in New York that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.
Find Insurance Agency Owner JobsInsurance Agency Owner Jobs by City in New York
Where New York roles are concentrated, by current openings.
Insurance Agency Owner Job Market in New York
A snapshot from current New York openings, updated as new roles post.
Who's Hiring
- Risk Specialists Companies Insurance Agency5

- Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency1

- Farmers Insurance1

Top Industries Hiring
- Insurance7
What New York Employers Look For
The qualifications that appear most often in insurance agency owner jobs across New York.
- Active state Property and Casualty or Life and Health insurance producer license
- Proven experience managing or owning an insurance book of business
- Strong sales skills with demonstrated client acquisition and retention results
- Familiarity with agency management systems such as Applied Epic or EZLynx
- Bachelor's degree in business, finance, or a related field preferred
- Designations such as CPCU, CIC, or ChFC viewed favorably by most carriers
Insurance Agency Owner Jobs in New York: Frequently Asked Questions
How many insurance agency owner jobs are there in New York?
There are 7+ insurance agency owner openings in New York on Migrate Mate as of June 2026, with the most roles in New York and Williamsville. New positions post regularly as employers across New York hire.
How much do insurance agency owners make in New York?
Insurance agency owners in New York earn a median of about $78,110 a year, based on May 2025 Bureau of Labor Statistics wage data, ranging from around $37,790 for the lowest 10% to over $173,750 for the top 10%. Pay rises with experience, specialty, and employer.
Which New York cities have the most insurance agency owner jobs?
New York and Williamsville have the most insurance agency owner openings in New York right now, with additional roles spread across smaller metros statewide.
Which companies hire insurance agency owners in New York?
Employers hiring insurance agency owners in New York include Risk Specialists Companies Insurance Agency, Arthur J. Glatfelter Agency, and Farmers Insurance, based on current listings on Migrate Mate as of June 2026.
Are there remote insurance agency owner jobs in New York?
Yes. About 0% of insurance agency owner openings tied to New York are remote or hybrid as of June 2026. The rest are on-site roles based in New York metros.
How do I apply for insurance agency owner jobs in New York?
You can apply to insurance agency owner jobs in New York directly on Migrate Mate. Search the listings above, find roles that match your experience and preferred New York location, then apply to each one that fits.
See All 7 Insurance Agency Owner Jobs in New York
Find roles in New York that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.
Find Insurance Agency Owner Jobs