Insurance Agent Jobs in Ohio
Insurance Agent jobs in Ohio are consistently in demand, with active hiring across property and casualty, life and health, and commercial lines insurance throughout a state anchored by major carriers and regional brokerages. Columbus, Cleveland, and Cincinnati are the largest hiring metros, home to well-established employers such as Nationwide, Progressive, and State Auto Insurance that maintain deep agent pipelines at every level from entry-level to senior producer. The most sought-after specialties in Ohio right now include personal lines, commercial accounts, and employee benefits. Find a role that fits below and apply directly.
Find Insurance Agent JobsOverview
Showing 5 of 85+ Insurance Agent jobs
The Goal
We need someone to own the space between an incoming request and its resolution.
Success looks like: Calls and emails are handled promptly, quotes aren't sitting unfinished, follow-ups happen before our competitors are finished quotes, client information stays organized streamlined with great documentation in our management system.
Formation for quote requests
Use comparative rating tools to review carrier options
Prepare and send quotes
Follow up on open quotes
Customer service requests
Part-time role to start with full time hours available with proven track record
Flexible schedule with agreed availability during business hours
Hybrid: Lewis Center office + work from home
Plan for 1–2 consistent office days initially for training, collaboration, and learning agency processes, with greater flexibility as the person becomes established
Potential to grow into a larger role and greater responsibility over time
Insurance experience/licensing is a plus, but not required
Crunelle Agency will cover the cost of obtaining an Ohio Property & Casualty license for the right person
Opportunity for a compensation review as licensing and responsibilities grow plus bonus potential
The role will be structured around agreed availability, responsibilities, and outcomes rather than a traditional set-shift position.
What We Need Help With
Client Service
Answer and return inbound calls and emails
Assist with client questions and service requests
Gather information and make sure requests get to resolution
Follow up on outstanding items
Quotes + New Business
Gather inmove clients from quote → follow-up → bind → issue
Organization + Workflow
Keep client records, notes, and tasks current
Track outstanding documents and next steps
Know what can be handled independently and what needs Jonathan
Help keep agency systems and processes organized
Who We're Looking For
Someone who is:
Warm, professional, and comfortable talking with clients
Reliable, responsive, and naturally good at following through
Organized and able to keep track of multiple moving pieces
Proactive and able to identify the next step
Comfortable working independently
Able to shift priorities when things get busy
Tech-comfortable and willing to learn
Someone who cares about the client experience and takes ownership
The workload can be unpredictable. Some days are busy with calls, quotes, and requests; others are quieter. We need someone who can handle both and use their time well without needing constant direction.
Experience
Insurance, account management, or customer service experience is helpful, especially experience with comparative raters or agency management systems. But finding the right person matters more.
We're open to training someone with the right personality, work ethic, and skill set and helping them become licensed.
What Crunelle Offers
Established, family-owned independent insurance agency
Competitive hourly rate based on experience
Flexible, hybrid work environment
Small team where your work makes a real impact
Direct access to agency leadership
Paid support toward insurance licensing
Bonus potential
Opportunity to learn the insurance business and grow into greater responsibility
Potential for compensation growth as licensing, experience, and ownership of the role increase
Expected hours: 15.0 – 40.0 per week
Work Location: Hybrid remote in Lewis Center, OH 43035
See All 85 Insurance Agent Jobs in Ohio
Find roles in Ohio that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.
Find Insurance Agent JobsInsurance Agent Jobs by City in Ohio
Where Ohio roles are concentrated, by current openings.
Insurance Agent Job Market in Ohio
A snapshot from current Ohio openings, updated as new roles post.
Who's Hiring
- State Farm22
- Shelter Insurance Companies15
- Farmers Insurance5
- Pioneer Agency4P
- wit3W
Top Industries Hiring
- Insurance
- Hospitality & Tourism
What Ohio Employers Look For
The qualifications that appear most often in insurance agent jobs across Ohio.
- Active Ohio Property and Casualty or Life and Health insurance producer license required
- Experience quoting and binding coverage using agency management or carrier systems
- Proven ability to prospect, retain, and grow a personal or commercial lines book
- Strong knowledge of Ohio insurance regulations and compliance requirements
- Ability to meet individual production goals within a defined sales territory
- Clear communication skills for explaining policy options to individuals and businesses
Insurance Agent Jobs in Ohio: Frequently Asked Questions
How do you become a insurance agent in Ohio?
To become a licensed insurance agent in Ohio, you must complete a state-approved pre-licensing education course, pass the Ohio insurance licensing exam administered through the Ohio Department of Insurance, and submit a license application through the National Insurance Producer Registry. Ohio requires separate licenses for each line of authority, such as property and casualty or life and health. A high school diploma is the minimum education requirement, though many employers prefer candidates with a college degree in business or a related field.
Which companies hire insurance agents in Ohio?
Employers hiring insurance agents in Ohio right now include State Farm, Shelter Insurance Companies, and Farmers Insurance, based on current listings on Migrate Mate as of September 2026. Ohio's concentration of large carrier headquarters and independent agency networks means consistent openings across both captive and independent agent models throughout the state.
Which Ohio cities have the most insurance agent jobs?
Columbus, Cleveland, and Cincinnati have the most insurance agent openings in Ohio. Columbus drives volume as the state capital and home to Nationwide's headquarters, while Cleveland and Cincinnati generate strong demand from regional carriers, independent brokerages, and the large commercial and employee benefits markets tied to each metro's corporate base.
Are there remote insurance agent jobs in Ohio?
Yes, and they are more common than in many fields, since a significant portion of insurance agent work involves phone, email, and digital quoting rather than in-person visits. About 41% of insurance agent openings tied to Ohio are remote or hybrid as of September 2026, reflecting ongoing flexibility among carriers and agencies. Personal lines sales, customer service roles, and inside sales positions are the most likely to offer remote or hybrid arrangements.
How can I get hired as a insurance agent in Ohio with little or no experience?
The most realistic entry path is obtaining your Ohio insurance producer license first, which signals commitment before your first interview. Large Ohio carriers such as Nationwide and Progressive run formal new-agent training programs that pair licensure support with supervised sales experience. Entry-level roles titled customer service representative, policy service agent, or insurance sales trainee are common starting points at both captive agencies and independent shops. Candidates moving from retail sales, banking, or financial services also find it easier to make the transition because Ohio employers value demonstrated sales ability over direct insurance experience.
Where can I find and apply to insurance agent jobs in Ohio?
You can find and apply to insurance agent jobs in Ohio on Migrate Mate, which lists current Ohio openings from employers across the state. Search the listings, find roles that fit your experience and preferred location, and apply directly to the ones that match.
See All 85 Insurance Agent Jobs in Ohio
Find roles in Ohio that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.
Find Insurance Agent Jobs