Math Teacher Jobs in Indiana

Math Teacher jobs in Indiana are concentrated in Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, and South Bend, where school districts and established institutions like Indianapolis Public Schools, Fort Wayne Community Schools, and the Metropolitan School District of Pike Township maintain consistent demand. Middle school and high school math, algebra, geometry, and AP calculus are the specialties drawing the most consistent postings, with openings at every level from first-year teachers to department chairs. Indiana's ongoing push to address teacher shortages keeps this one of the more active hiring markets in the Midwest. Scan the live roles below and apply to whichever ones fit.

Find Math Teacher Jobs

Overview

Open roles17
Top employerParamount Schools of Excellence
Top cityIndianapolis, IN
Cities hiring9
Work type80% On-site
Top industryEducation

Showing 5 of 17+ Math Teacher jobs

Portage Township Schools
PHS - Math Teacher
We won't show you this job again
Portage Township Schools
Added 1d ago
PHS - Math Teacher
Portage Township Schools
Portage, Indiana
Business Development
Growth Marketing
Marketing
Teaching Certification
1,001-5,000

Have you applied for this role?

Paramount Schools of Excellence
Middle School Math Teacher
We won't show you this job again
Paramount Schools of Excellence
Added 6d ago
Middle School Math Teacher
Paramount Schools of Excellence
Indianapolis, Indiana
Program Management
Project & Program Management
Project Management
Teaching Certification

Have you applied for this role?

Stride, Inc.
Substitute Math Teacher
We won't show you this job again
Stride, Inc.
Added 1w ago
Substitute Math Teacher
Stride, Inc.
Indiana
Higher Education
K-12 Teaching
Teaching & Instruction
Remote (US)
High school
5,001-10,000

Have you applied for this role?

Lake Ridge New Tech Schools
Middle School Math Teacher
We won't show you this job again
Lake Ridge New Tech Schools
Added 2w ago
Middle School Math Teacher
Lake Ridge New Tech Schools
Gary, Indiana
Higher Education
K-12 Teaching
Teaching & Instruction
$47k - $70k/yr
Teaching Certification

Have you applied for this role?

Perry Township School District
Long Term Leave - 7th Grade Math Teacher
We won't show you this job again
Perry Township School District
Added 2w ago
Long Term Leave - 7th Grade Math Teacher
Perry Township School District
Indianapolis, Indiana
Corporate Training
Higher Education
K-12 Teaching
Substitute Teaching Certification

Have you applied for this role?

See All 17 Math Teacher Jobs in Indiana

Find roles in Indiana that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.

Find Math Teacher Jobs

Math Teacher Jobs by City in Indiana

Where Indiana roles are concentrated, by current openings.

Indianapolis
7 jobs
Gary
2 jobs
Elkhart
1 job
Portage
1 job
Boonville
1 job
Frankfort
1 job
Lafayette
1 job
Brownsburg
1 job
Fort Wayne
1 job

Math Teacher Job Market in Indiana

A snapshot from current Indiana openings, updated as new roles post.

Who's Hiring

Paramount Schools of Excellence
Paramount Schools of Excellence3 open roles
Stride
Stride1 open role
T
Thrival Indy Academy1 open role

Top Industries Hiring

  • Education

What Indiana Employers Look For

The qualifications that appear most often in math teacher jobs across Indiana.

  • Active Indiana teaching license with a secondary mathematics content area endorsement
  • Bachelor's degree in mathematics, mathematics education, or a closely related field
  • Student teaching experience or completed field placement in a secondary classroom
  • Proficiency in Indiana Academic Standards for Mathematics and Common Core alignment
  • Ability to differentiate instruction for diverse learners including IEP and ELL students
  • Experience with learning management systems and classroom data platforms such as PowerSchool

Math Teacher Jobs in Indiana: Frequently Asked Questions

How do you become a math teacher in Indiana?

To become a math teacher in Indiana, you need an Indiana teaching license issued by the Indiana Department of Education, which requires completing an approved educator preparation program and passing the required Praxis content-area exams in mathematics. Most candidates earn a bachelor's degree in mathematics education, complete a supervised student teaching practicum, and apply through the Indiana Educator Licensing System. Candidates already licensed in another state can apply for an Indiana license through reciprocity.

How much do math teachers make in Indiana?

Math teachers in Indiana earn a median of about $78,780 a year, based on May 2025 Bureau of Labor Statistics wage data, ranging from around $50,490 for the lowest 10% to over $133,480 for the top 10%. Pay rises with experience, specialty, and employer.

Which companies hire math teachers in Indiana?

Companies currently hiring math teachers in Indiana include Paramount Schools of Excellence, Stride, and Thrival Indy Academy, per current listings on Migrate Mate as of September 2026. Indiana's larger public school districts, charter networks, and private and Catholic school systems across the Indianapolis metro and northern Indiana cities tend to post the most consistent openings throughout the hiring cycle.

Which Indiana cities have the most math teacher jobs?

Indianapolis, Gary, and Indiana have the most math teacher openings in Indiana. Indianapolis anchors demand as the state's largest metro with multiple large public and charter school districts, while Fort Wayne and South Bend generate steady postings through their own urban school systems and the regional Catholic diocesan schools that serve those communities.

Are there remote math teacher jobs in Indiana?

Yes, but they're rare. About 20% of math teacher openings tied to Indiana are remote or hybrid as of September 2026, reflecting the fact that most classroom instruction requires an in-person presence. The remote openings that do exist are typically with Indiana-based online charter schools or virtual tutoring programs that serve K-12 students statewide.

How can I get hired as a math teacher in Indiana with little or no experience?

The most realistic entry path is securing a student teacher placement in an Indiana district that has a strong record of hiring its own student teachers. Indianapolis Public Schools and Fort Wayne Community Schools both work closely with university preparation programs and regularly hire new graduates into open classroom positions. Candidates without a completed license can pursue an Indiana Transition to Teaching permit, which allows you to teach while finishing licensure requirements. A strong Praxis math score and a willingness to accept a position in a high-need school or subject area gives first-year candidates a clear advantage.

Where can I find and apply to math teacher jobs in Indiana?

You can find and apply to math teacher jobs in Indiana on Migrate Mate, which lists current openings from Indiana school districts and education employers. Search the roles below, find the ones that match your license level, grade band, and location, and apply directly to each position that fits.

See All 17 Math Teacher Jobs in Indiana

Find roles in Indiana that match your experience and apply in just a few clicks.

Find Math Teacher Jobs