Insurance Visa Sponsorship Jobs in Indiana
Indiana's insurance industry centers around Indianapolis, home to major insurers like Anthem, CNO Financial Group, and OneAmerica Financial Partners. The state's competitive market and established financial services sector create regular demand for international talent in actuarial science, underwriting, claims analysis, and risk management roles.
See All Insurance Indiana JobsOverview
Showing 5 of 1,079+ insurance visa sponsorship jobs in indiana jobs


Have you applied for this role?


Have you applied for this role?


Have you applied for this role?


Have you applied for this role?


Have you applied for this role?
See all 1,079+ Insurance Visa Sponsorship Jobs in Indiana jobs
Sign up for free to unlock all listings, filter by visa type, and get alerts for new Insurance Visa Sponsorship Jobs in Indiana roles.
Get Access To All Jobs
Who We Are
NFP, an Aon company, is a multiple Best Places to Work award winner in Business Insurance. We are an organization of consultative advisors and problem solvers. We help companies and individuals around the globe address their most significant risk, workforce, wealth management and retirement challenges through custom solutions and a people-first approach.
Summary
Responsible for broking new and renewal business, handling all aspects of the placements from initial market selection through policy delivery to client. Ensure all clients’ needs are promptly and accurately satisfied, all deadlines are met, and service standards are achieved. This is a full-time opportunity open to a hybrid or remote CST schedule. In addition to base salary, this role is eligible to earn a 25% commission on first-year new business.
Essential Duties And Responsibilities
- Proactively coordinate broking around the renewal cycle in accordance to NFP’s service model standards and timelines
- Define success and direct broking activity to achieve the optimal outcome for the client/prospect; ensure a go-to-market strategy is in place for each broking engagement
- Effectively negotiate with insurance carriers demonstrating an unmistakable command of the risk; drive financial and non-financial outcomes that support organic revenue development and retention, seize upon opportunities to creatively upsell and cross-sell, leading to greater client product density and expanded account margin
- Collaborate with account management team and client to ensure complete, timely and highly differentiated submissions are presented to markets, respond to carrier queries, compile carrier quote proposals and critically and comparatively analyze each, and present prospects or clients with a clear summary of the marketing process, and a proposal with recommendations
- Support team members with proposal preparation for existing and prospective clients
- Respond to client queries and concerns to resolve issues promptly
- Review binders and policies to ensure terms and conditions are accurately reflected
- Attend client meetings as a part of the team to strengthen and hone client communication and presentation skills
- Assist in the development of sales documents, presentations, stewardship reports, and RFP responses for prospective new clients
- Present proposals to producers and account management teams and participate in client meetings
- Prepare coverage comparisons, diagnostics, consolidated coverage/policy analyses, letters and reports under the direction of the Senior Broker or Broking Team Leader
- Develop productive business relationships with key insurance underwriters and local NFP account management teams
- Cultivate a thorough understanding of markets to better assist the broking team
- Maintain accurate client and policy information in NFP’s Epic agency management system
- Drive the deployment of data and analytics to provide meaningful program insights for clients and the broking team
- Ensure client, broking, and brokerage data files are maintained in a complete, organized and timely fashion
- Execute on NFP’s broking strategies, including strategic carriers, panels, and preferred wholesaler utilization
- Develop and maintain thorough knowledge of insurance marketplace and available products and services
- Engage account team and markets to coordinate cross-sell and up-sell initiatives; effectively closes coverage gaps or deficiencies, supports the account team in maximizing client product density, enhancing account profitability and margin
Knowledge, Skills, And/or Abilities
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills
- Ability to successfully interact with a variety of people
- Excellent negotiation skills – ability to adjust approach to effectively drive optimal outcomes depending on different personalities
- Demonstrated ability to work independently and as part of a team
- Strong attention to detail with strong analytical skills, both quantitative and qualitative
- Excellent organizational skills with the ability to adjust to changing workload and priorities
- Able to coordinate resources and responsibilities
- Self-motivated and determined with positive attitude and sense of urgency
- Proven technical competency and creativity demonstrating excellence in developing and delivering innovative property and casualty solutions
- Confident, poised and interactive - when client-facing communicates effectively, demonstrates emotional intelligence, and understands how to tailor responses in a variety of dynamic situations
- Proficient in Microsoft Office Suite
- Experience with Epic (agency management system) a plus
Education And/or Experience
Bachelor’s degree preferred
Minimum of three to five years insurance experience
Certificates, Licenses, Registration
P&C License required
Advanced industry designation(s) (e.g. CPCU, CIC, ARM) a plus
What We Offer
We're proud to offer a competitive salary, PTO & paid holidays, 401(k) with match, exclusive discount programs, health & wellness programs, and more. Our PeopleFirst culture focuses on building and nurturing lifelong relationships with our employees because, at the end of the day, we exist to be there for others. The base salary range for this position is $60,000 – $65,000. The base salary offered will be determined by factors including, but not limited to, experience, credentials, education, certifications, skill level required for the position, the scope of the position, and geographic location. Actual base salary offered will be determined on a case-by-case basis. In addition to the base salary, this position may be eligible for performance-based incentives.

Who We Are
NFP, an Aon company, is a multiple Best Places to Work award winner in Business Insurance. We are an organization of consultative advisors and problem solvers. We help companies and individuals around the globe address their most significant risk, workforce, wealth management and retirement challenges through custom solutions and a people-first approach.
Summary
Responsible for broking new and renewal business, handling all aspects of the placements from initial market selection through policy delivery to client. Ensure all clients’ needs are promptly and accurately satisfied, all deadlines are met, and service standards are achieved. This is a full-time opportunity open to a hybrid or remote CST schedule. In addition to base salary, this role is eligible to earn a 25% commission on first-year new business.
Essential Duties And Responsibilities
- Proactively coordinate broking around the renewal cycle in accordance to NFP’s service model standards and timelines
- Define success and direct broking activity to achieve the optimal outcome for the client/prospect; ensure a go-to-market strategy is in place for each broking engagement
- Effectively negotiate with insurance carriers demonstrating an unmistakable command of the risk; drive financial and non-financial outcomes that support organic revenue development and retention, seize upon opportunities to creatively upsell and cross-sell, leading to greater client product density and expanded account margin
- Collaborate with account management team and client to ensure complete, timely and highly differentiated submissions are presented to markets, respond to carrier queries, compile carrier quote proposals and critically and comparatively analyze each, and present prospects or clients with a clear summary of the marketing process, and a proposal with recommendations
- Support team members with proposal preparation for existing and prospective clients
- Respond to client queries and concerns to resolve issues promptly
- Review binders and policies to ensure terms and conditions are accurately reflected
- Attend client meetings as a part of the team to strengthen and hone client communication and presentation skills
- Assist in the development of sales documents, presentations, stewardship reports, and RFP responses for prospective new clients
- Present proposals to producers and account management teams and participate in client meetings
- Prepare coverage comparisons, diagnostics, consolidated coverage/policy analyses, letters and reports under the direction of the Senior Broker or Broking Team Leader
- Develop productive business relationships with key insurance underwriters and local NFP account management teams
- Cultivate a thorough understanding of markets to better assist the broking team
- Maintain accurate client and policy information in NFP’s Epic agency management system
- Drive the deployment of data and analytics to provide meaningful program insights for clients and the broking team
- Ensure client, broking, and brokerage data files are maintained in a complete, organized and timely fashion
- Execute on NFP’s broking strategies, including strategic carriers, panels, and preferred wholesaler utilization
- Develop and maintain thorough knowledge of insurance marketplace and available products and services
- Engage account team and markets to coordinate cross-sell and up-sell initiatives; effectively closes coverage gaps or deficiencies, supports the account team in maximizing client product density, enhancing account profitability and margin
Knowledge, Skills, And/or Abilities
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills
- Ability to successfully interact with a variety of people
- Excellent negotiation skills – ability to adjust approach to effectively drive optimal outcomes depending on different personalities
- Demonstrated ability to work independently and as part of a team
- Strong attention to detail with strong analytical skills, both quantitative and qualitative
- Excellent organizational skills with the ability to adjust to changing workload and priorities
- Able to coordinate resources and responsibilities
- Self-motivated and determined with positive attitude and sense of urgency
- Proven technical competency and creativity demonstrating excellence in developing and delivering innovative property and casualty solutions
- Confident, poised and interactive - when client-facing communicates effectively, demonstrates emotional intelligence, and understands how to tailor responses in a variety of dynamic situations
- Proficient in Microsoft Office Suite
- Experience with Epic (agency management system) a plus
Education And/or Experience
Bachelor’s degree preferred
Minimum of three to five years insurance experience
Certificates, Licenses, Registration
P&C License required
Advanced industry designation(s) (e.g. CPCU, CIC, ARM) a plus
What We Offer
We're proud to offer a competitive salary, PTO & paid holidays, 401(k) with match, exclusive discount programs, health & wellness programs, and more. Our PeopleFirst culture focuses on building and nurturing lifelong relationships with our employees because, at the end of the day, we exist to be there for others. The base salary range for this position is $60,000 – $65,000. The base salary offered will be determined by factors including, but not limited to, experience, credentials, education, certifications, skill level required for the position, the scope of the position, and geographic location. Actual base salary offered will be determined on a case-by-case basis. In addition to the base salary, this position may be eligible for performance-based incentives.
Job Roles in Insurance in Indiana
See all 1,079+ Insurance Indiana jobs
Sign up for free to unlock all listings, filter by visa type, and get alerts for new Insurance Indiana roles.
Get Access To All JobsFrequently Asked Questions
Which insurance companies in Indiana sponsor work visas?
Major Indiana insurers that historically sponsor visas include Anthem (Indianapolis), CNO Financial Group, OneAmerica Financial Partners, and Baldwin & Lyons. Regional offices of national carriers like State Farm, Allstate, and Progressive also maintain operations in Indianapolis and may sponsor for specialized roles like actuaries, data scientists, and senior underwriters.
How to find insurance visa sponsorship jobs in Indiana?
Use Migrate Mate to search specifically for insurance positions in Indiana that offer visa sponsorship. Filter by location (Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, Evansville) and role type (actuary, underwriter, claims analyst). Many Indiana insurers prefer candidates with actuarial credentials or advanced degrees in statistics, finance, or economics from local universities like Purdue or Indiana University.
What visa types are most common for insurance jobs in Indiana?
H-1B visas dominate for actuarial and analytical roles requiring specialized knowledge in risk modeling, statistics, or advanced mathematics. TN visas work for Canadian and Mexican professionals in actuarial science. O-1 visas occasionally apply for senior executives or consulting actuaries with exceptional track records in insurance innovation or regulatory expertise.
Which Indiana cities have the most insurance visa sponsorship opportunities?
Indianapolis leads with 70% of Indiana's insurance visa sponsorship jobs, hosting major carriers' headquarters and regional offices. Fort Wayne offers opportunities with smaller insurers and regional operations. Evansville and Bloomington have limited but growing insurance sectors, primarily focused on agricultural and specialty insurance products.
Are prevailing wages different for insurance roles in Indiana compared to coastal states?
Yes, prevailing wages for insurance professionals in Indiana typically run 15-25% lower than New York or California markets. However, the lower cost of living often results in comparable purchasing power. Actuarial roles still command competitive wages due to skill scarcity, while underwriting and claims positions reflect regional market rates.
What is the prevailing wage for sponsored insurance jobs in Indiana?
U.S. employers sponsoring a visa must pay at least the prevailing wage, which is what workers in the same role, area, and experience level typically earn. The Department of Labor sets this rate to make sure companies aren't hiring foreign workers simply because they'd accept lower pay than a U.S. worker. It varies by job title, location, and experience. You can look up current prevailing wage rates for any occupation and location using the OFLC Wage Search page.
See which Insurance Indiana employers are hiring and sponsoring visas right now.
Search Insurance Indiana Jobs